Closed Captions vs Subtitles: What's the Difference?

GuidesShort-form

Subtitles are for people who can hear the audio but don't understand the language, so they translate the dialogue. Captions are for people who can't hear it, so they include sound effects, music and who is speaking as well as the words. Closed captions can be turned on and off; open captions are part of the picture. goodgoodclips.com adds open, animated captions to every clip, the kind short-form video uses.

The difference at a glance

SubtitlesClosed captionsOpen captions
Made forHearing viewers who don't speak the languageDeaf and hard-of-hearing viewersEveryone, including people watching on mute
IncludesDialogue, usually translatedDialogue plus sound effects, music and speaker namesWhatever the creator adds, usually the dialogue
Can be turned off?YesYes, with the CC buttonNo, they're burned into the video
Where you see themFilms and streaming servicesTV and YouTubeTikTok, Reels and Shorts

The U.S. government's Section 508 guidance puts it plainly: subtitles are intended for hearing audiences and rarely identify speakers or sounds such as music, so they don't meet accessibility standards on their own. Captions do.

Section508.gov: open captions are a permanent part of the video and can't be turned off; closed captions can be turned on and off. Subtitles translate dialogue for hearing audiences and don't indicate audio information.
Open vs closed captions, and captions vs subtitles. Screenshot: Section508.gov, checked 17 November 2026.

What are SDH subtitles?

SDH means subtitles for the deaf and hard of hearing. The Described and Captioned Media Program describes SDH as just like subtitles, but including sound effects, speaker identification and other important non-speech information, as close to verbatim as possible. Netflix's partner help calls SDH a mix of the two: technically subtitles, with the same audience and content as closed captions. In everyday use, people often treat SDH and CC as the same thing.

Open vs closed captions

Closed captions live in a separate file or track that the viewer switches on. On YouTube you add them in YouTube Studio under Subtitles: upload a file, auto-sync a transcript, type them or auto-translate, per YouTube's help page. Automatic captions only come in the video's own language.

Open captions are rendered into the video. Nobody has to find a button, they look the same in every app, and they can be styled: the font, colour and a highlighted key word are part of the edit. That's why short-form creators burn them in.

Which should you use?

  • Long YouTube videos: closed captions. Upload an accurate caption file or check YouTube's automatic ones.
  • TikTok, Reels and Shorts: open captions, styled and burned in, for the many people who scroll with the sound off.
  • A different-language audience: subtitles, translated.
  • Accessibility: captions, with important sounds and speaker changes written out, not just the words.

Captions on every clip

goodgoodclips.com transcribes each word with its timing, in any of 16 languages, and burns animated captions into every 1080p clip, with the key word on each line highlighted. Fix a word in the transcript and the captions follow. If a platform takes a separate caption file, download the clip's captions as SRT or WebVTT too.

The goodgoodclips editor's captions tab with caption styles to choose from and a clip previewing animated captions.
Caption styles in the goodgoodclips editor. More in how to add captions to a video.

Turn videos into viral clips.

Start clipping

What to read next